Behind Manassas City Hall, the block at 9007 Center Street is about 2.2 acres. It holds old industrial buildings, a fuel canopy with pumps, and part of the City Hall parking lot, and it sits right next to the historic Meredith House. The city bought the former Manassas Ice and Fuel property in 2025. Now it's the largest piece of downtown still waiting on a decision.
On October 26, 2026, City Council voted on the rezoning that would let a five-story apartment building and a public parking garage go up there. The vote tied 3-3, and then it tied 3-3 again. If you're weighing a home in or near Old Town, the garage in this plan matters most, because it decides when the rest of the downtown plan can move. When the tie gets broken now depends on Manassas's council calendar more than on anything about the project.
Two Motions, Same Split
Potomac Local reported how each member voted. The two motions split the council the same way, just in reverse.
| Motion on Oct. 26 | Yes | No | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Defer until 2028 | Theresa Coates Ellis, Sonia R. Vásquez Luna, Ashley Hutson | Mark D. Wolfe, Ralph J. Smith, Tom Osina | Failed |
| Approve first reading | Tom Osina, Ralph J. Smith, Mark D. Wolfe | Theresa Coates Ellis, Sonia R. Vásquez Luna, Ashley Hutson | Failed |
The city's meeting summary says neither motion got a majority and the ordinance "is expected to return for consideration at a future Council meeting." Potomac Local also reported that on the recording, the clerk said the item both "is passed" and "is deferred," and it noted that no development agreement or final garage funding came with the first reading.
Why Six Votes Instead of Seven
A resignation earlier in the fall left six members voting on Center Street. Mayor Michelle Davis-Younger resigned effective September 30, and at the same October 26 meeting, Council chose Ralph Smith as interim mayor out of three council members who wanted the job, Manassas Daily reported. He serves until a special mayoral election on November 2, 2027.
Under the Manassas City Charter, a council member who becomes mayor gives up the council seat once qualified as mayor. The city's elected-officials page now shows Smith's former seat as vacant. The charter also limits what the mayor can do in a vote:
"The mayor shall have no right to vote in the council except that in every case of a tie vote of the council, the mayor shall vote to break the tie not later than the next regular council meeting."
Smith voted on both Center Street motions as a council member. Council chose him as interim mayor that same night, October 26, and the city's elected-officials page lists him as sworn in on October 27. The mayor's office is the one the charter gives the tie-breaking vote. The city calendar lists the next regular Council meeting as November 9. The draft ordinance attached to the October 26 agenda was written for approval at that November 9 meeting. The city hasn't publicly said how the tie-break clause applies to this vote.
The Seats That Change Hands January 1
The council will look different soon. Three seats were on the November 3, 2026 ballot: the seats held by Ellis and Vásquez Luna, plus Smith's vacant seat. Each term ends December 31, 2026. Ashley Hutson was elected in 2025, and her term runs through 2028.
InsideNoVa reported a seven-candidate field. Ellis was the only incumbent running, and Vásquez Luna ran for the House of Delegates instead. The candidates on the ballot were Democrats Dianne Lane, Jill M. Spall, and Helen Anne Zurita, Republican Theresa Coates Ellis, and independents Eugene E. "Doc" Brown, Lynn Forkell Greene, and Colin J. Turner.
The charter says new terms start January 1 after the election. Vice Mayor Wolfe proposed a December 14 organizational meeting and swearing-in, and Council expected to take up that idea in November. Back at the September 2 Planning Commission hearing, one of the public comments the staff report recorded was a request to wait until a new City Council is sworn in before deciding.
These are the dates that matter for this decision, in order:
- September 30, 2026: Mayoral resignation takes effect
- October 26, 2026: Two 3-3 votes, and Smith is chosen interim mayor
- November 3, 2026: Three council seats on the ballot
- November 9, 2026: Next regular Council meeting on the city calendar
- December 14, 2026: Proposed organizational meeting and swearing-in
- January 1, 2027: New council terms begin under the charter
- November 2, 2027: Special election for mayor
What the Rezoning Would Actually Build
Under the application, CenterSt, LLC, the development entity of MLG Construction Management Services, would build a five-story, 162-unit apartment building with one- and two-bedroom units, next to a five-story garage with 536 spaces. The design includes stepped-back upper floors, a public park near Meredith House, rooftop gardens, a pool, and a walking path along the railroad. Ten apartments are proffered at fair-market rent for households earning 80% of area median income. The proposal started at 179 units and was reduced to 162.
The garage would be built privately but owned by the city. Potomac Local reported roughly 360 public spaces. The capital improvement plan estimates the public portion at about $12 million, which the city would pay while the developer builds it. The rest of the spaces would serve the apartments, City Hall, and Blue Lot permit holders.
Why the Garage Is the Real Hinge
City staff, including Planning and Community Development Director Matthew Arcieri, presented this rezoning as one part of a larger downtown plan. That plan includes a separate hotel on the former Olde Towne Inn property, a City Hall annex, and better connections to Mathis Avenue. The hotel isn't part of this rezoning, and Potomac Local reported that it would need the parking built first. The city's fact sheet adds dining, retail, and meeting space to the hotel concept. The traffic study modeled the apartments and garage in 2029 and a hotel phase in 2031. Those are study years for the analysis, not a construction schedule.
So a delay on this vote also delays the parking the hotel depends on and changes how City Hall parking works while it waits. That's what the deferral motion put on the table. A 2028 date would have moved the start of the whole sequence by more than a year.
What People Said at the Hearings
The Planning Commission recommended approval unanimously on September 2, and city staff recommended approval as consistent with the Comprehensive Plan. The commission asked Council to weigh the city's overall net cost, and it asked for one selected green-building standard and advance notice to neighbors within two blocks before construction. Those changes were written into the final proffers.
The public comments raised:
- Traffic on Center Street and how it would affect the nearby roundabout
- Pedestrian safety around the site
- Losing parking on Center Street
- Stormwater and drainage on the site
- Affordability and the city's finances
At the September 28 Council hearing, InsideNoVa reported that some speakers raised traffic and preservation, while others supported the housing as a way to bring more customers downtown. The same report said Historic Manassas Inc. president Mark Olsen told Council the HMI board supported the project after meeting with 30 businesses and restaurants. At the October 26 meeting, Potomac Local described public comment as heavily opposed, with concerns about density, scale next to Meredith House, traffic, and how fast the process was moving. A smaller group spoke in favor of replacing an industrial site.
Where This Fits for an Old Town Buyer
Buyers in Manassas right now have more time to think than they did a year ago. The Prince William REALTORS® September 2026 report, which combines Prince William County, Manassas, and Manassas Park, counted 1,172 active listings. That's up 29.8% from September 2025, and homes took 30 days on market. With more inventory, there's more room to look into the block next door before you write an offer.
Center Street also isn't the only downtown housing project moving forward. In October 2026, the city announced that Good Housing, Virginia LLC had been awarded 4% Low-Income Housing Tax Credits for the Landing at Cannon Branch. That's a proposed 100-unit workforce housing building on the former DMV site, with priority for City employees.
A Few Straight Answers
Is the hotel part of this vote? No. The hotel concept is on the former Olde Towne Inn property and would need the garage's parking first.
How many units would be income-restricted? Ten, at fair-market rent for households earning 80% of area median income.
Where can I follow the next step? The city keeps a downtown redevelopment page with status updates and meeting dates for the Center Street rezoning.
If you're thinking about a home within walking distance of Center Street, I'm glad to go through what this block could become, keep an eye on the council dates with you, and talk about how that fits your plans. At Home With Ally is here when you're ready. Let's connect.